Ulisse Aldrovandi

Ornithologiae tomus alter - 1600

Liber Decimusquartus
qui est 
de Pulveratricibus Domesticis

Book 14th
concerning
domestic dust bathing fowls

transcribed by Fernando Civardi - translated by Elio Corti - reviewed by Roberto Ricciardi

188

 


The navigator's option display ->  character ->  medium is recommended

Socrates sane apud eundem Aristophanem[1], Strepsiadem reprehendere [188] videtur, quod ἀλεκτρυόνα in utroque sexu proferat, itaque iubet, eum faeminam ἀλεκτρύαιναν vocare ficto vocabulo, et poëtico, ut a λέων fit λέαινα, marem vero ἀλέκτορα. Videtur autem, inquit Scholiastes, vulgaris haec consuetudo tum fuisse, faeminam quoque ἀλεκτρυόνα nominandi, ut patet ex hisce Aristophanis verbis[2]:

Γύναι τί τὸ ψόφημα ἐστί; Ἡ ἀλεκτρυών
Τὴν κύλικα καταβέβληκεν. Οἰμωξουσάγε.

Et in Platonis D<a>edalo[3]: ἐνίοτε πολλαί τῶν ἀλεκτρυόνων ὑπηνέμια βίᾳ τίκτουσι ὠά πολλάκις. Ὁ δὲ παῖς ἔνδον τὰς ἀλεκτρυόνας σοβεῖ. Attici quidem etiam Gallinas sic vocabant{,}<.> Et Theopompus: Vocant vero Gallinam etiam ἀλεκτρύαιναν. Haec Scholiastes: sed locus quo<d>[4] ad authorum citationes non recte distinctus emendari potest ex Athenaeo[5], apud quem ita legitur. Cratinus, inquit, ἀλεκτρυόνα in faeminino genere dixit. Item Strattis Αἱ δ’ἀλεκτρυόνες ἅπασαι καὶ τὰ {κορίδια}[6] <χοιρίδια> τέθνηκεν. Et Anaxandrides Rhodius {Comicns}<Comicus> Ὀχευομένας τὰς ἀλεκτρυόνας θεοροῦσιν ἄσμενοι. Et Theopompus[7] Ἄχθομαι δ’ἀπολωλεκώς ἀλεκτρυόνα τίκτουσαν ᾿ῳά πάγκαλα. Et Aristophanes[8] ᾿ῼόν μέγιστον τέτοκεν, ὡς ἀλεκτρυών.

In Aristophanes it seems that Socrates is quite scolding Strepsiades because he says alektrna for both sexes, and so he bids to call the female alektrýainan by a newly coined and poetic word, likewise léaina – lioness - is coming from léřn - lion, but the male is aléktora. The scholiast says that on the other hand it seems that then there was this common practice to call also the female alektryóna, as is evident from these words of Aristophanes:

Gýnai psóphëma estí? Hë alektryřn
Tën kýlika katabéblëken. Oimřxouságe.

O woman what’s this noise? It’s the hen
That knocked down a cup. She wailed
.

And in Daedalos of comedy writer Plato: eněote pollŕi třn alektryónřn hypënémia bíai tíktousi řá pollákis. O dč paîs éndon tŕs alektrnas sobeî. - Sometimes many hens lay wind-eggs – sterile - against their will. The boy drives the hens inside. In fact the Attic inhabitants called in this way also the hens. And the comic writer Theopompus says: But they call the hen also alektrýainan. This is what the scholiasts says. But the passage, not too much accurate regarding the quotation of various authors, can be emended on the basis of Athenaeus, where we read as follows. He says: Cratinus used alektryóna in the feminine gender. Likewise Strattis Ai d’alektryónes hápasai, kŕi tŕ choirídia téthnëken - All hens and little sows are died. And the comic poet Anaxandrides of Rhodes Ocheuoménas tŕs alektryónas theoroűsin ásmenoi - Delighted, they gaze at hens being mounted. And the comic writer Theopompus: Ŕchthomai d’apolřlekřs alektryóna tíktousan řiá pánkala - I feel sorry to have lost the hen which was laying very fine eggs. And Aristophanes: Řión mégiston tétoken, hřs alektryřn - She has laid a very large egg, like a hen.

Thomas {magister} <Magister>[9] quoque annotat, vocem ἀλεκτρυών significare marem, et faeminam, et Hesychius[10] veteres ἀλεκτρυόνας Gallinas vocare scribit. Gallus etiam dicitur ἀλέκτωρ, a quo fit, ἀλεκτορίς, Gallina, quam posteriorem vocem Varinus, et Thomas Magister poëticam esse dicunt: ἀλέκτωρ vero vocabulum esse ἀδόκιμον. Verum cum Aristoteles[11] ἀλεκτορίδα etiam nominet, ac Galenus[12] ἀλεκτρυόνος καὶ ἀλεκτορίδος αἷμα dicat: itaque ego vocem ἀλεκτρύαινα prorsus ἀδόκιμον, ἀλέκτωρ vero poëticam {tantum}[13] contra illos esse dixerim; qui cum ἀλεκτορίς poëticum faciant, poëtae nullius testimonium adducunt, et ego quoque nullum ex poëtis hac voce usum memini, ἀλέκτορα vero in prosa nemo dixit, sed poëtae aliquot, Aristophanes, Theocritus, Cratinus, aliique[14].

Also Thomas Magister annotates that the word alektryřn means the male and the female, and Hesychius writes that the ancients called alektrnas the hens. The rooster is also called aléktřr, whence alektorís, the hen, is formed, and the latter word Thomas Magister and Varinus say is poetic: but aléktřr is a derogatory word. But being that also Aristotle uses the word alektorída and that Galen says alektryónos kaě alektorídos haîma - blood of cock and hen: then, in opposition to them – Varinus and Magister, I would say that the word alektrýaina is quite adókimon, derogatory, while aléktřr is poetic: they, when setting out alektorís as poetic, adduce the testimony of no poet, and I also don’t remember any poet who used this word, and really no one said aléktora in prose, but some poets, Aristophanes, Theocritus, Cratinus and others.

Ἀλεκτορίς vero Athenaeo non Gallina est, sed Gallus. Usus, inquit, nostro tempore obtinuit, ut Gallinae Ὄρνιθες, et Ὀρνίθια dicantur, Galli vero ἀλεκτρυόνες, et ἀλεκτορίδες. Apud Varinum ἀλεκτρίς pro Gallina legitur, sed forte impressoris culpa pro ἀλεκτορίς, ut videtur. Reperitur et ἀλεκτόριος pro ἀλεκτόρειος. Ἀλέκτωρ vero Gallus dicitur, quod nos, ut apud Athenaeum[15] est, ἐκ τοῦ λέκτρου, id est e cubili excitet. Ille, ut videtur, intelligit esse ex alpha privativo, et λέκτρον, quod nos ἄλεκτρος faciat. Eustathius vult esse ex alpha privativo, et verbo λέγω, id est cubo; ut videlicet sit λέκτωρ, deinde praefixo alpha privativo ἀλέκτωρ: unde ἀλεκτορίσκος. Caeterum etiamsi ἀλέκτωρ ex α privativo, et λέγω deducamus, ἀλεκτρυών, quod idem est, quod ἀλέκτωρ[16], Gallus nempe, et interdum etiam Gallina, ut mox ex Aristophane diximus, et Athenaeo, ex α privativo, et λέκτρον potius fieri dicendum est. Hanc vocem nempe ἀλεκτρυών Homeri saeculum, teste Varino non agnovit. Utebantur nimirum antiquitus, ut diximus paulo ante, tantum voce ὄρνις de Gallo in genere masculino, de Gallina in faeminino. Cum vero ἀλεκτρυών nomen viri est, cuius Homerus[17] meminit, servat o magnum in genitivo, secundum Varinum, secundum vero Eustathium mutat[18].

In Athenaeus alektorís is not the hen but the cock. He says: In our times the custom obtained that the hens are called órnithes – birds - and orníthia -birdies, the cocks on the contrary alektryónes and alektorídes. In Varinus alektrís is read for hen, but perhaps, as it seems, in place of alektorís owing to the printer. There is also found alektórios instead of alektóreios - gallinaceous. Really, the cock is called aléktřr because, as we find in Athenaeus, ek toű léktrou, that is, it brings out of the bed. He, as it seems, is thinking that it comes from an alpha privative and léktron - nuptial bed, being that it makes us álektros - without marriage. Eustathius of Thessalonica wants that it is coming from an alpha privative and the verb légř - to fall to lie, i.e. I lie; that is like it were léktřr and then, with an alpha privative placed before, aléktřr: whence alektorískos - cockerel. On the other hand, although we derive aléktřr from privative alpha and légř, alektryřn, which is the same as aléktřr, and precisely the cock and sometimes also the hen, as we have just told from Aristophanes and Athenaeus, we must say that they come rather from an alpha privative and léktron. Homer’s age, according to Varinus, did not know this word, i.e. alektryřn. In ancient time, as I said a short while ago, they just used only the word órnis in the masculine gender for rooster and in the feminine gender for hen. But when alektryřn is the name of a man, mentioned by Homer, according to Varinus it keeps the letter omega in the genitive, on the contrary according to Eustathius is changing it - into omicron.

Βοσκάς ὀρταλίς Nicandro[19] gallina est domestica, sive altilis. Βρητὸς apud Hesychium, et Varinum gallus anniculus. Ἠϊκανός[20] gallinaceus, ut iidem interpretantur. Ἱππαλεκτρυών dicitur magnus gallus apud Aristophanem[21]. Κέρκνος iisdem Hesychio, et Varino scilicet, vel Accipiter est, vel Gallinaceus, sed Accipiter potius meo iudici<o>, isque Circus: uti etiam Κῆρυξ, quae vox Suidae pariter, et Varino Accipitris genus est, et Gallinaceus. Κίκιῤῥος Gallinaceus, Hesychius, et Varinus. Κικκὸς oxytonum, Gallinaceus, paroxytonum vero parva cicada[22], et Κίκκα paroxytonum, Gallina, Iidem. Videtur autem vox per onomatopoeiam facta. Κοκκοβόας ὄρνις[23] de Gallinaceo accipiendum videtur apud Sophoclem[24], ut vult Eustathius[25], nimirum quoque a voce, de qua verbum κοκκύζειν Graeci usurpant: videtur itaque epitheton esse.

Boskás ortalís - fatted young hen - in Nicander is a domestic hen, or a battery hen. Brëtňs in Hesychius and Varinus is a year-old rooster. Ëďkanós is the cock, as the same authors undesrstand. In Aristophanes a large rooster is called hippalektryřn - horsecock, fabulous animal. For the same authors, i.e. Hesychius and Varinus, kérknos is either the hawk or the cock, but rather the hawk in my judgment, and precisely the circus: as also kęryx - the herald, a word that, alike in both Suidas and Varinus is a kind of hawk and the cock. Kíkirros – cock - for Hesychius and Varinus is the cock. Kikkós oxytonum is the cock, paroxytonum on the contrary is a small cicada, and kíkka paroxytonum is the hen, for the same authors. And it seems and onomatopoeic words. It seems that in Sophocles kokkobóas órnis must be taken as referring to the rooster, like Eustathius thinks, without doubt also from the song, from which the Greeks take the verb kokkýzein - to go boo, or to crow a cock-a-doodle-doo: therefore it seems to be an epithet.

Κόρκορα ὄρνις, Pergaeis Hesychius, et Varinus. Κορυθών ἀλεκτρυών, αἱ νεανίδες{.}<,> Iidem. Forte autem sic nominatus fuerit Gallus, quod κόρυθα[26] id est, cristam gerat: et eadem ratione fortassis etiam κορυνθεύς apud eosdem, sed quae vox eis etiam cophinum et calathum significat. Κόσκικοι, οἱ κατοικίδιοι Ὄρνιθες{.}<,> Iidem. Apparet autem priorem vocem a κικκός formari. Κοττοὶ, Gallinacei a crista capitis sic dicti apud eosdem in Προκόττα, quod est, κεφαλῆς τρίχωμα. Κόττος, ὄρνις, sed equum quoque aliqui sic vocabant{.)}<,> Iidem. Et rursus Κοττοβολεῖν τὸ παρατηρεῖν τινὰ ὄρνιν. Κοττυλοιοί κατοικίδιοι ὄρνεις: sed Varinus legit κοττυλιοί per iota in penultima. Hesychius vocem κόττος alibi in dictione κόττη generaliter pro qualibet ave accipi scribit, proprie vero esse Gallinaceum. Κοτίκας Gallus{.}<,> Iidem. Κροκίας apud Plutarchum[27] Gallus est, quem Hermanubidi immolari solere tradit. Κύμβαι ὄρνιθες. Iidem. Videntur autem aves simpliciter intelligendae, quoniam cymbateutae etiam Varino sunt aucupes.

Kórkora is a bird for the inhabitants of Perge, according to Hesychius and Varinus. Korythřn alektryřn, ai neanídes – the rooster standing up, the young girls - the same authors. But perhaps the rooster was so named because it bears the kórytha, i.e. the comb: and probably for the same reason is also called koryntheús by the same authors, but for them this word also means big basket and hamper. Kóskikoi, hoi katoikídioi órnithes - Kóskikoi, the domestic birds, the same authors. But it seems that the first word is made from kikkós - the cock. In the same source the roosters are called kottoě because of the comb they have on head, when they are dealing with prokótta, which is kephalës tríchřma - head hair. Kóttos órnis, kóttos, a bird -, but somebody called in this way also the horse, the same authors. And again Kottoboleîn, to paratëreîn tinŕ órnin - Kottoboleîn, to observe a bird. Kottyloioí katoikídioi órneis - Kottyloioí domestic birds: but Varinus reads kottyliοí with an iota in the penultimate syllable. Hesychius writes that the word kóttos - the fish Cottus gobio-elsewhere in the form kóttë, is generally interpreted for whatever bird, but that properly it is the cock. Kotíkas is a cock, the same authors. In Plutarch krokías - saffron colored - is a rooster, and he tells it is custom to sacrifice it to Hermanubis. Kýmbai órnithes - birds cymba. The same authors. But it seems that they must be simply meant as birds, since also in Varinus cymbateutae are bird catchers.


188


[1] Aristophanes Clouds 662-63. (Lind, 1963) – In greco ὁ ἀλεκτρυών č il gallo, ἡ ἀλεκτρυών la gallina, ὁ ἀλέκτωρ č il gallo, anche il marito; dal primo vocabolo, per coniazione comica, Aristofane in Nuvole 666 riporta ἡ ἀλεκτρύαινα, che viene tradotto con gallessa.

[2] Aristophanes Amphiaraus, Fragment I (ed. by A. Meineke) in Fragmenta Comicorum Graecorum II, 2 (Berlin, 1840), 953; F. W. Hall and W. M. Geldart, Oxford text of Aristophanes, Fragment 18; edition of the Clouds by W. J. M. Starkie (London, 1911), 159. (Lind, 1963)

[3] Plato Comicus: in A. Meineke, op. cit., 619. (Lind, 1963) – Conrad Gessner, Historia Animalium III (1555), pag. 401: Et in Platonis (Aristophanis, Athenaeus. positum est καὶ πλάτων, pro καὶ πάλιν a librarijs) Daedalo, Ἐνίοτε πολλαί τῶν ἀλεκτρυόνων ὑπηνέμια βίᾳ τίκτουσι ὠά πολλάκις. Ὁ δὲ παῖς ἔνδον τὰς ἀλεκτρυόνας σοβεῖ. – Quindi si tratterebbe, secondo Ateneo, di una commedia di Aristofane e non di Platone.

[4] Conrad Gessner, Historia Animalium III (1555), pag. 401: Sed locus, quod ad authorum citationes, non recte distinctus emendari potest ex Athenaeo, cuius verba subieci.

[5] IX,15,373e-16,374d.

[6] Forse il testo di Ateneo letto da Aldrovandi aveva effettivamente korídia, fanciulle, diminutivo di kórë, ragazza; ma il testo receptus č choirídia, diminutivo di choîros, scrofa (cho<i>rídia). – Si puň tuttavia presumere con quasi assoluta certezza che si tratta di un errore tipografico oppure di uno scorretto download praticato sul testo di Gessner, visto che Conrad Gessner, Historia Animalium III (1555), pag. 401 riporta: item Strattis, Αἱ δ’ἀλεκτρυόνες ἅπασαι καὶ τὰ χοιρίδια τέθνηκεν.

[7] In Pace. Conrad Gessner, Historia Animalium III (1555), pag. 401: Et Theopompus in Pace, Ἄχθομαι δ’ἀπολωλεκώς ἀλεκτρυόνα τίκτουσαν ᾿ῳά πάγκαλα.

[8] From Aristophanes’ Daedalus; the fragment is found in A. Meineke, op. cit., 1016 [in Fragmenta Comicorum Graecorum]; it is quoted also by Eustathius, 1479-1528 and by Photius, 624-28. Aldrovandi wrongly refers it to the Peace. (Lind, 1963) – Come giustamente rileva Lind, Aldrovandi ha commesso un semplicissimo ma grave errore: nella nota a bordo pagina appone il riferimento in Pace come appartenente ad Aristofane, mentre non fornisce alcun riferimento per il comicoTeopompo, al quale, stando a Gessner, appartiene Pace.

[9] Thomas Magister, ed. by F. Ritschl (Halle, 1832). (Lind, 1963)

[10] Hesychius, I, 16; see note 23 and Latte’s edition, I, 101. (Lind, 1963)

[11] Aristotle History of Animals 6. 1, 558b 27. (Hereafter referred to as Aristotle H. A.) (Lind, 1963)

[12] Galen De Simplicium Medicamentorum Temperamentis et Facultatibus in Medici Graeci (ed. by C. G. Kuehn, Leipzig, 1821-33); first Paris edition, 1530; another at Leyden, 1561. (Hereafter cited as Galen De Simpl.) (Lind, 1963)

[13] Questo tantum č riportato a casaccio da Aldrovandi, rendendo oltretutto indaginosa la traduzione. Infatti nel testo di Gessner – da cui č stato praticato il download – tantum č in correlazione con et. Invece nel testo di Aldrovandi bisognerebbe associare tantum a poëticam oppure a contra. - Conrad Gessner, Historia Animalium III (1555), pag. 401: Itaque ego vocem ἀλεκτρύαινα prorsus ἀδόκιμον dixerim, ἀλέκτωρ vero poeticam tantum contra Varinum et Thomam Magistrum: qui cum ἀλεκτορίς poeticum faciant, poetae nullius testimonium proferunt, et ego quoque nullum ex poetis hac voce usum memini.

[14] Se crediamo a Gessner – e conviene crederci - questi altri sono i Settanta in Proverbi 30,31 (che č un libro poetico dell'Antico Testamento) e Kiranide, ammesso che si tratti di Kiranide e che il suo testo fosse considerato poesia. - Conrad Gessner, Historia Animalium III (1555), pag. 401: ἀλέκτορα vero in prosa nemo dixit, sed poetae aliquot, Aristophanes, Theocritus, Cratinus. item Septuaginta Prov. 30. et Kirań. - Proverbi 30,31: gallus succinctus lumbos, “il gallo, che passeggia spavaldo fra le galline, il caprone, che marcia in testa al suo gregge, il re, quando arringa il suo popolo.” (La Sacra Bibbia, Edizioni Paoline, 1958) – Settanta: καὶ ἀλέκτωρ ἐμπεριπατῶν θηλείαις εὔψυχος καὶ τράγος ἡγούμενος αἰπολίου καὶ βασιλεὺς δημηγορῶν ἐν ἔθνει.

[15] IX,16,374d.

[16] Eustazio, pag. 182,11 (ad Iliadem II 103); pag. 1479,28 (ad Odysseam I 10): apň toű légř léktřr e aléktřr.

[17] There is a marginal reference to Homer Iliad, Book 17; this must be to line 602: “great-hearted son of Alectryon,” the only reference in Homer to the word for chicken in Greek, although a proper name here. (Lind, 1963)

[18] Eustazio, pag. 1120,12 (ad Iliadem XVII 602): Óti Alektryřn kýrion keîtai entaűtha ou phylássřn tň ř en tëi genikęi hřs Ëlektrýřn.

[19] Alexipharmaca, 293.

[20] Forse da ëřs, l’uccello che canta al mattino. - Perhaps from ëřs, the bird singing in the morning.

[21] Ranae 937 ecc.

[22] κίκους = giovane cicala = young cicada.

[23] kókky = cucců, voce del cuculo + boář = mando un grido - kókky = cuckoo, the voice of the cuckoo + boář = to bawl.

[24] Sophocles, Fragment 900; F. Ellendt, Lexicon Sophocleum (sec. ed. by H. Genthe, 1872; photographic reprint, 1958), 390; A. C. Pearson, The Fragments of Sophocles, III (1917), 34, Fragment 791. (Lind, 1963)

[25] ad Odysseam IV 10 (1479,44).

[26] Il sostantivo femminile κόρυς, genitivo κόρυθος, significa elmo, casco.

[27] Il sostantivo maschile κροκίας in Plutarco De Iside et Osiride 375e significa color zafferano, riferito al gallo. - Plutarco, Moralia, Iside e Osiride 61 – 375d-e: δ Ὄσιρις ἐκ τοῦ ὁσίου <καὶ> ἱεροῦ τοὔνομα μεμιγμένον ἔσχηκε· κοινὸς γάρ ἐστι τῶν ἐν οὐρανῷ καὶ τῶν ἐν ᾅδου λόγος· ὧν τὰ [375e] μὲν ἱερὰ, τὰ δ ὅσια τοῖς παλαι ἔθος ἦν προσαγορεύειν. δ' ἀναφαίνων τὰ οὐράνια καὶ τῶν ἄνω φερομένων λόγος Ἄνουβις, ἔστι δὲ ὅτε καὶ Ἑρμάνουβις ὀνομάζεται, τὸ μὲν, ὡς τοῖς ἄνω, τὸ δὲ, ὡς τοῖς κάτω προσήκων. Διὸ καὶ θύουσιν αὐτῷ τὸ μὲν λευκὸν ἀλεκτρυόνα, τὸ δὲ κροκίαν, τὰ μὲν εἰλικρινῆ καὶ φαν, τὰ δὲ μικτὰ καὶ ποικίλα νομίζοντες. - Sic ergo Osiris nomen habet ex hosio et hiero (quod est sancto et sacro) conflatum: communis enim est ratio eorum quae in coelo et apud inferos sunt, quorum altera hiera, altera hosia veteres nuncupabant. Jam qui coelestia ostendit Anubis, superiorum quasi ratio (ano enim supra est), aliquando etiam Hermanubis usurpatur: altero nomine superioribus, altero inferis scilicet conveniente: itaque ei immola{ba}nt alias album, alias flavum gallum: supera sincera et manifesta, infera mixta et varia esse docentes. (Plutarchi Scripta Moralia tomus primus, Frederic Dübner, Parisiis, Editore Ambrosio Firmin Didot, 1868) - Osiride ha ricevuto il nome dall'unione di hósios (santo) e hierós (sacro): infatti il modo di esprimere le cose che stanno in cielo e agli inferi č equivalente; e gli antichi avevano l'abitudine di chiamare hierŕ (sacre) le prime, hósia (sante) le seconde. Siccome Anubi č colui che svela le cose celesti e la spiegazione razionale delle cose che si muovono verso l'alto, e talvolta č anche chiamato Ermanubi, in quanto il primo nome riguarda ciň che sta in alto, il secondo ciň che sta in basso. Per cui gli immolano anche un gallo bianco nel primo caso, nel secondo caso uno color zafferano, volendo significare nel primo caso le cose pure e pulite, nel secondo caso le cose mescolate e multiformi. (traduzione di Elio Corti – revisione di Roberto Ricciardi) – Aldrovandi ne riparlerŕ a pagina 256.